Advertising disclosure: This article contains SoFi referral links. If you open an eligible SoFi product through them, I may receive a referral bonus at no extra cost to you β and in some cases you may receive a welcome bonus too. I only share products I think are worth a look, but I'm not a financial advisor and this isn't financial advice. Rates, fees, and terms change and are set by SoFi, not me β always confirm the current details on SoFi's official pages before applying.
A personal loan is worth considering if you have a specific, one-time need and a steady income that covers the payment with room to spare. The most common case is paying off credit card balances at a lower rate. It's a poor fit if your monthly spending already runs ahead of your income, because the loan adds a fixed bill without changing why the balances built up.
SoFi is one lender worth getting a quote from. It offers fixed-rate, unsecured personal loans from $5,000 to $100,000, and you can see an estimated rate before you apply without affecting your credit score. Whether its offer is a good one depends on how it compares with what you're paying now and with what other lenders quote you. Most of this guide is about making that comparison.
I'm not going to quote rates or fees. They change, they depend on your credit and income, and SoFi's affiliate rules don't allow it. SoFi's personal loan page has the current terms.
Who a personal loan suits, and who it doesn't
With a personal loan you get a lump sum up front and repay it in fixed monthly payments over a set number of years. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau describes it as a closed-end loan: unlike a credit card, you can't borrow against it again as you pay it down. That fixed end date is the main thing it has going for it.
It tends to suit you if:
- You're carrying card balances at a high rate and can qualify for a loan rate that's clearly lower.
- You have a large, necessary expense, such as a repair or a medical bill, that would otherwise go on a card.
- Your income is stable enough that the payment is manageable even in a tight month.
It tends not to suit you if:
- You'd be borrowing to cover ordinary monthly bills. The shortfall will still be there next month, plus a loan payment.
- The rate you're offered isn't lower than what your cards charge. Then you're paying for tidiness, and one due date isn't worth much on its own.
- You need less than $5,000, which is SoFi's minimum. A credit union or a smaller lender is the place to look.
- The debt you want to deal with is student loans. That's a different product with its own trade-offs, especially for federal loans, and I cover it in the guide to refinancing student loans with SoFi.
When consolidating card debt helps
Consolidation saves money when two things are true. The loan's APR is lower than the rate you're paying across your cards, and the term isn't so long that the extra months of interest cancel out the lower rate.
The second one is easy to miss. The CFPB's page on consolidating credit card debt puts it this way: "Although your monthly payment might be lower, it may be because you're paying over a longer time." A smaller payment can still mean a bigger total.
So do the arithmetic before you compare anything else. Add up your card balances and note each card's APR. For any loan offer, multiply the monthly payment by the number of months and add any fee. Then compare that with what you'd pay if you put the same monthly amount toward the cards. If the loan total isn't clearly lower, the loan isn't doing much for you.
SoFi can also send loan money straight to your card issuers rather than to your bank account. If you know you'd be tempted to spend part of a lump sum, that's a useful option to pick.
When it backfires
The usual way a consolidation loan goes wrong: the loan pays off the cards, the cards now show zero balances and full credit lines, and over the next year the balances creep back. Now there's a loan payment and card debt.
The CFPB is blunt about this: "Taking on new debt to pay off old debt may just be kicking the can down the road." A loan changes the interest rate and the schedule. It doesn't change the spending that produced the balances.
If you consolidate, decide what happens to the cards before you sign. Take them out of your wallet and delete them from the shopping sites where they're saved. I'd also work out what was going on the cards in the first place, because if it was groceries and gas, the fix is in the budget and the loan is only a cheaper way to carry the old balance.
The other ways it backfires are in the loan itself: a fee large enough to eat the interest savings, or a long term chosen for the low payment.
