If you run a small site and you're choosing between Google Analytics 4 and a privacy-friendly tool like Plausible or Fathom, the decision mostly comes down to two things: whether you run Google ads, and how much you'd pay to skip the analytics part of your cookie banner.
GA4 is free, goes deeper, and connects to Google Ads and Search Console. It also sets cookies, so in the EU and UK it generally has to wait for consent. Plausible and Fathom are paid, show far less, and don't set cookies at all. For a blog that only needs to know which pages get read and where visitors come from, the simpler tools are enough. If you buy Google ads or need funnels and audiences, GA4 is the practical choice.
For transparency: nothing below is an affiliate link.
The comparison at a glance
Everything in this table was checked on each vendor's own site in October 2026. Prices and plans change, so confirm before you buy.
| GA4 | Plausible | Fathom | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | Free | From $9/month | From $15/month |
| Free tier | Yes | No, 30-day trial | No, 7-day trial |
| Cookies | Yes | No | No |
| Open source | No | Yes (AGPLv3) | No |
| Self-hosting | No | Yes, free edition | No |
| Google Ads link | Yes | No | No |
Plausible's $9 starter plan covers up to 10,000 monthly pageviews. Fathom's $15 entry plan covers up to 100,000. Both charge more as traffic grows, so a small site pays less on Plausible and a busier one may find Fathom cheaper. Run your own numbers on the Plausible pricing page and the Fathom pricing page.
What Plausible and Fathom do differently
Both give you one dashboard: visitors, pageviews, top pages, referrers, countries, devices, and any goals you set up, such as a newsletter signup. You can read it in a minute, which is most of the appeal.
Neither sets a cookie. To count unique visitors, each one combines the visitor's IP address and browser user agent with a secret value that changes every day, then turns that into a scrambled identifier. Both vendors say they never store the raw IP address. Plausible's data policy says the daily value is deleted after 24 hours, and Fathom's data page describes the same approach.
That design has a cost. A visitor who returns tomorrow, or switches from phone to laptop, is counted as a new person. You get accurate daily traffic and no picture of returning readers over weeks.
The two differ on openness. Plausible publishes its code, and its free Community Edition can be self-hosted under the AGPLv3 licence. You run and update the server yourself, and Plausible says that edition leaves out some paid features, including funnels and ecommerce revenue tracking. If that route appeals, read the guide to running your own services on a cloud VPS first, because the monthly server bill and the maintenance time are real costs. Fathom's current product is closed source and hosted only. An older open-source version, Fathom Lite, is still on GitHub but no longer gets new features.
Both scripts are also much smaller than Google's tag. Plausible puts its script at about 2.5 KB against roughly 135 KB for GA4. That's the vendor's own figure, and one analytics script rarely decides your page speed, but it's worth knowing if you're working on Core Web Vitals for a small blog.
Matomo and Simple Analytics sit in the same category. Check the same points for them: cookies, hosting, price, and what the vendor says about consent.
What GA4 does that they don't
GA4 costs nothing for a standard property, and it's far more capable:
- It links to Google Ads, so you can measure campaigns and build remarketing audiences.
- It has explorations, funnels and path reports for following a visitor through several steps.
- It can export raw event data to BigQuery (you pay Google Cloud's storage and query charges).
- It tracks users across sessions, so you can see returning visitors.
The price is complexity. GA4 takes real time to learn, and most of its reports answer questions a small content site never asks. It also ties your measurement to an advertising company, which some site owners and readers are uncomfortable with.
