Most SEO problems on a small site trace back to one of three things: Google can't reach the page, the page doesn't answer what the searcher wanted, or the site gives nobody a reason to trust it. This checklist covers those first, then the on-page, structure and speed items that matter once the basics are in place.
Work through it top to bottom. The groups are in priority order, because a fast page with a perfect title tag still gets no traffic if it isn't indexed.
You only need free tools: Google Search Console (verify your site first), PageSpeed Insights, and Google search itself. Paid crawlers save time on big sites, but nothing below requires one.
How to read the labels
Each item ends with one of two labels. Google-documented means the advice comes from Google's own documentation, mainly the SEO Starter Guide. Good practice means it's sensible and widely done, but Google doesn't spell it out.
Neither label means "ranking factor". Google doesn't publish a list of those, and no item here guarantees a position. Where Google does say its ranking systems use something, I've said so in the item.
1. Can Google crawl and index the page?
- Your site is in Google at all. Search
site:yourdomain.com. If you see your pages, you're indexed. It's a rough check and won't list everything. Google-documented. - The pages you care about are indexed. In Search Console, open Indexing β Pages and read the reasons listed for pages that aren't indexed. For a single page, paste its address into URL Inspection. Google-documented.
- Nothing is blocking Google by accident. URL Inspection shows whether crawling and indexing are allowed. A leftover
noindextag or a robots.txt rule from a staging site is a common cause. Google-documented. - robots.txt isn't doing a job it can't do. Google says robots.txt manages crawling and is not a way to keep a page out of search. If you want a page gone, use
noindexor put it behind a login. Google-documented. - Google sees what visitors see. In URL Inspection, run a live test and look at the screenshot. If the content is missing, your scripts or styles may be blocked or failing to load. Google-documented.
- A sitemap is submitted. Check Search Console β Sitemaps for errors. Google says a well-linked site of about 500 pages or fewer may not need one, but it helps a new site with few links pointing to it. Being in the sitemap doesn't guarantee indexing. Google-documented.
- Each piece of content lives at one address. If the same page loads at several URLs, redirect the extras or set a canonical. URL Inspection shows which version Google picked. Google-documented.
If you'd rather run these checks as one timed session, my one-hour SEO audit walkthrough puts them in order.
2. Does the page answer the query?
- The page type matches what searchers want. Search your target query and look at page one. If every result is a step-by-step tutorial and yours is a product roundup, you've misread the query. Good practice.
- Google is showing the page for the right searches. In Search Console, open Performance, filter by the page, and read the queries. If they don't match what the page is about, the page is unclear or aimed at the wrong term. Good practice.
- It adds something the current results don't. Google's self-assessment asks whether content provides original information, reporting, research or analysis. A rewrite of the top five results fails that test. Google-documented.
- The answer comes early. Put the direct answer in the first few paragraphs, then explain. Good practice.
- It's as long as the topic needs. Google says it has no preferred word count, so padding a post to hit a number is wasted effort. Google-documented.
- Updates are real. Revise a page when the facts change. Google lists changing a date without substantially changing the content as a warning sign. Google-documented.
- One page per topic. If two of your posts chase the same query, merge them and redirect the weaker one. Good practice.
Most pages that fail this group were aimed at the wrong query from the start. That's a research problem, and I cover it in the guide to picking keywords you can realistically rank for.
Google's own questions for this group are on its helpful content page. It's worth reading once in full.
3. On-page basics
- Every page has a unique, accurate title. Google uses the title element as a main source for the headline shown in results. Run a
site:search to see how yours appear and spot duplicates. Google-documented. - The meta description summarizes the page. Google sometimes uses it for the snippet and often writes its own from the page text. There's no length limit, but long ones get cut off. Google-documented.
- Headings describe what's under them. Google says the order of headings doesn't matter for Search. Clear headings still help readers and screen readers. Good practice.
- URLs use readable words.
/internal-linking-guidetells people more than/?post=12847. Don't rename URLs that already get traffic unless you redirect the old ones. Google-documented. - Images have descriptive alt text and sit near the text they relate to. Google-documented.
- Structured data is valid, if you use it. It's optional and never guarantees a rich result. Test a page with Google's Rich Results Test. My schema markup guide covers which types are worth adding. Google-documented.
4. Site structure and internal links
- Every page is linked from at least one other page. Google finds most pages by following links. In Search Console, open Links β Internal links and look for important pages with few or none. Google-documented.
- Link text says where the link goes. "How to write an affiliate disclosure" tells readers and Google what's on the other side. "Click here" doesn't. Google-documented.
- Important pages are a few clicks from the home page. Good practice.
- Related pages link to each other. A post on email funnels should point to your other email posts. Good practice.
- Internal links don't hit dead ends. The Page indexing report lists URLs returning "Not found (404)". Fix the links that point to them, and avoid long redirect chains, which Google says hurt crawling. Google-documented.
Internal links are the part of this list you control completely. I've written up how to plan internal links across a whole site separately.
